The Baldwin Wallace football prgram has had a total of 248 All-Ohio Athletic Conference first-team selections. The complete list of football players, postions, and years are listed below
| Name | Position | Year |
| Dennis Boynar | DB | 1963 |
| Bob Carter | OL | 1963 |
| Larry Shinn | OL | 1963 |
| Dave Dorum | LB | 1964 |
| Ernie Prince | RB | 1964 |
| Jerry Roberts | WR & DB | 1964 |
| Dave Dorum | LB | 1965 |
| Steve Hayes | DB | 1965 |
| John Terakedis | HB | 1966 |
| Pete Baumgartner | HB | 1968 |
| Chuck Mayville | FB | 1968 |
| Greg Nackley | OL | 1968 |
| Bob Quackenbush | DL | 1968 |
| Mike Blake | QB | 1969 |
| Dave Coad | DB | 1969 |
| Tom Graham | WR | 1969 |
| Larry Hoon | OL | 1969 |
| Ron Stephonic | LB | 1969 |
| Greg Thomas | DL | 1969 |
| Dave Coad | DB | 1970 |
| Tom Graham | WR | 1970 |
| Tom Maher | OL | 1970 |
| Dave Coad | DB | 1971 |
| Tom Graham | WR | 1971 |
| John Groff | OL | 1971 |
| Greg Peck | DL | 1971 |
| John Yezerski | OL | 1971 |
| Willie Avery | WR | 1972 |
| Mike Heaton | PK | 1972 |
| Dale Herbert | DB | 1972 |
| John Groff | OL | 1972 |
| Tom McKenzie | DL | 1972 |
| John Yezerski | OL | 1972 |
| Claude Butler | DB | 1973 |
| Everett Heard | DB | 1973 |
| Ray Dickerhoof | OL | 1974 |
| Gary Nash | LB | 1974 |
| Dave Sierleja | DL | 1974 |
| Mark Summers | LB | 1974 |
| Jim Tressel | QB | 1974 |
| Les Wojciechowski | OL | 1974 |
| Mike Albert | WR | 1975 |
| Bob Beichler | DB | 1975 |
| Tim Carras | DB | 1975 |
| Sam Crumpton | WB | 1975 |
| Chuck Hall | DL | 1975 |
| Jim Haubert | DL | 1975 |
| Rick Intorcio | DL | 1975 |
| Jim Kuhner | LB | 1975 |
| Russ MacConnell | OL | 1975 |
| Ken Preseren | QB | 1975 |
| Mike Sabock | PK | 1975 |
| Doug Shook | OL | 1975 |
| Dan Bowersox | RB | 1976 |
| Ilio Di Paolo | DL | 1976 |
| Dean Janitzki | DL | 1976 |
| George Key | OL | 1976 |
| Andy Laibe | LB | 1976 |
| Scott Olds | WR | 1976 |
| Jim Patton | DB | 1976 |
| Mike Sabcok | PK | 1976 |
| Joe Smith | LB | 1976 |
| Robert Spicer | OL | 1976 |
| Mike Washington | S | 1976 |
| Roger Andrachik | FB | 1977 |
| Paul Ernst | RB | 1977 |
| Duke Flahery | DT | 1977 |
| Jim Host | LB | 1977 |
| Gary Jenning | OL | 1977 |
| Tim McMahon | OL | 1977 |
| Paul Petrella | DL | 1977 |
| Greg Rufus | LB | 1977 |
| Gary Stelter | DB | 1977 |
| Roger Andrachik | FB | 1978 |
| Bill Davis | DL | 1978 |
| Jeff Jenkins | OL | 1978 |
| Gary Monda | LB | 1978 |
| Paul Petrella | DL | 1978 |
| Bill Rickert | LB | 1978 |
| Doug Schiefer | P | 1978 |
| Gary Stelter | DB | 1978 |
| Joe Surniak | QB | 1978 |
| Fred Buchanan | DL | 1979 |
| Mark Cassesse | DB | 1979 |
| Dan Craine | WR | 1979 |
| Dan Delfino | DL | 1979 |
| Mike Hoon | LB | 1979 |
| Mike Kelly | OL | 1979 |
| Tom Kelsey | QB | 1979 |
| Doug Schiefer | P | 1979 |
| Chris Zito | DL | 1979 |
| Brett Albright | QB | 1980 |
| Dan Delfino | DL | 1980 |
| Mike Graven | DB | 1980 |
| Paul Guhde | OL | 1980 |
| John Host | LB | 1980 |
| Chuck Krajacic | LB | 1980 |
| Jim Mackie | LB | 1980 |
| Dave Nofzinger | LB | 1980 |
| Bill Ochalek | OL | 1980 |
| Joe Portale | FB | 1980 |
| Larry Rosati | DL | 1980 |
| Doug Schiefer | P | 1980 |
| Dave Ward | WR | 1980 |
| Keith Boedicker | DL | 1981 |
| Lance Currens | WR | 1981 |
| Mike Graven | DB | 1981 |
| Dave Heinemann | QB | 1981 |
| Chuck Krajacic | OL | 1981 |
| Rick Macer | WR | 1981 |
| Dave Nofzinger | LB | 1981 |
| Pete Primeau | DL | 1981 |
| Larry Rosati | DL | 1981 |
| Steve Varga | PK | 1981 |
| Paul Wood | OL | 1981 |
| Wally Blewit | DL | 1982 |
| Keith Boedicker | DL | 1982 |
| Dave Croutch | OL | 1982 |
| Lance Currens | WR | 1982 |
| Randy Edwards | DB | 1982 |
| Dino Mastantuono | RB | 1982 |
| Larry Mills | DB | 1982 |
| Pete Primeau | DL | 1982 |
| Larry Rosati | DL | 1982 |
| Mark Rodriquez | LB | 1982 |
| Jeff Rutherford | OL | 1982 |
| Steve Varga | PL | 1982 |
| Joe Belcik | DL | 1983 |
| Lance Currens | WR | 1983 |
| John Ferritto | DL | 1983 |
| Mike Hansinger | DB | 1983 |
| John Price | RB | 1983 |
| Dave Rodriquez | LB | 1983 |
| Jeff Rutherford | OL | 1983 |
| Dave Starfield | P | 1983 |
| Steve Varga | PK | 1983 |
| Kert Boedicker | DL | 1984 |
| Ken Gabriel | OL | 1984 |
| Dave Miller | WR | 1984 |
| Brian Moore | QB | 1984 |
| Rick Newsock | DB | 1984 |
| John Price | RB | 1984 |
| Mark Schwertner | OL | 1984 |
| Phil Trupo | DL | 1984 |
| Kert Boedicker | DL | 1985 |
| Stacy Brandt | DL | 1985 |
| Mike Diederich | DB | 1985 |
| John Price | RB | 1985 |
| Mark Schwertner | OL | 1985 |
| Phil Trupo | DL | 1985 |
| Jeff Welcsh | LB | 1985 |
| Mike Carney | WR | 1986 |
| Shawn Gorman | P | 1986 |
| Craig Mears | HB | 1986 |
| Chris Riemenschneider | OL | 1986 |
| Jerry Sponseller | S | 1986 |
| Todd Sprunger | LB | 1986 |
| Jeff Welcsh | LB | 1986 |
| Lorne Conyers | RB | 1987 |
| Shawn Gorman | P | 1987 |
| Wade Massad | PK | 1987 |
| Greg Profancik | LB | 1987 |
| Dirk Riemenschneider | OL | 1987 |
| Tom Sokolowski | TE | 1987 |
| Jerry Sponseller | S | 1987 |
| Kirk Davis | OL | 1988 |
| Doug Haubert | DL | 1988 |
| Matt Kubinski | LB | 1988 |
| Phil Medvetz | LB | 1988 |
| Doug Schreck | FB | 1988 |
| Scott Wilson | OL | 1988 |
| Erik Young | QB | 1988 |
| Dan Andrews | RB | 1989 |
| Chuck Geiss | Returns | 1989 |
| Doug Haubert | DL | 1989 |
| Phil Medvetz | LB | 1989 |
| Chuck Geiss | RB | 1990 |
| Colin Johnson | LB | 1990 |
| Mike Laubacher | DB | 1990 |
| Mike Rodak | DL | 1990 |
| Bob Anderson | DL | 1991 |
| Mike Barbetta | PK | 1991 |
| Jim Clardy | LB | 1991 |
| John Koz | QB | 1991 |
| Todd Pipoly | DB | 1991 |
| Tom Serdinak | P | 1991 |
| Jeff Stetler | OL | 1991 |
| Jim Clardy | LB | 1992 |
| Tom Garfield | OL | 1992 |
| Eric Hyduk | DB | 1992 |
| Lance Yandell | WR | 1992 |
| Adrian Allison | DL | 1993 |
| Mike Barbetta | PK | 1993 |
| Scott Hershiser | LB | 1993 |
| Tom Kne | LB | 1993 |
| Bill Linder | DB | 1993 |
| Lance Yandell | WR | 1993 |
| Tom Farkas | LB | 1994 |
| Jason Klein | OL | 1994 |
| Tony Oden | LB | 1994 |
| Tyrone Price | RB | 1994 |
| Phil Sahley | DL | 1994 |
| Phil O'Toole | DB | 1994 |
| Mike Kromer | OL | 1995 |
| Tony Oden | LB | 1995 |
| Tyrone Price | RB | 1995 |
| Mike Zografos | WB | 1995 |
| Adam Iacona | RB | 1996 |
| Dave Price | WR | 1996 |
| Fred Saylor | OL | 1996 |
| Jason Ochs | LB | 1997 |
| Fred Saylor | OL | 1997 |
| Scott Barwidi | LB | 1998 |
| Mike Blackburn | OL | 1998 |
| Geoff Helmlinger | QB | 1998 |
| Pat Knaze | WR | 1998 |
| Tim Obergefell | DB | 1998 |
| Scott Barwidi | LB | 1999 |
| Joe Dobies | DL | 1999 |
| Todd Bacik | LB | 2000 |
| Matt Caine | LB | 2000 |
| Joe Dobies | DL | 2000 |
| Dave Schierbaum | LB | 2001 |
| Mark Anders | RB | 2002 |
| Greg Kock | S | 2002 |
| Dave LaBahn | WR | 2002 |
| Rob Wittensolder | DL | 2002 |
| Mark Anders | RB | 2003 |
| Rob Becker | P | 2003 |
| Ian Formaz | OL | 2003 |
| Greg Koch | S | 2003 |
| Dan Larlham | QB | 2003 |
| Nate Mitchell | DL | 2003 |
| Nate Wilder | TE | 2003 |
| Justin Andes | DB | 2004 |
| Brandon Hedges | RB | 2004 |
| Justin Princehorn | LB | 2004 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | P | 2004 |
| Joe George | LB | 2005 |
| Ryan Lewis | DL | 2005 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | P | 2005 |
| Brandon Hedges | RB | 2006 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | P | 2006 |
| Luke Chronister | LB | 2007 |
| Kevin Soflkiancs | P | 2007 |
| Matt Lepley | WR | 2008 |
| Keith Darbutt | DL | 2010 |
| Ryan Kish | LB | 2010 |
| Travis Barnhill | OL | 2011 |
| Ryan Dugan | S | 2011 |
| Derron Hamilton | DL | 2011 |
| Sonny Hazelwood | DL | 2011 |
| Josiah Holt | Special Teams | 2011 |
| Aaron Hurd | TE | 2011 |
| Tyler Lohr | RB | 2011 |
| Brett Thompson | LB | 2011 |
| Josiah Holt | WR | 2012 |
| Max Wagner | DL | 2012 |
| Jason Cook | OL | 2013 |
| Matt Harmon | P | 2013 |
| Luke Riemenschneider | DL | 2014 |
| Tyler Moeglin | QB | 2015 |
| Alex Kurtz | OL | 2016 |
| Sam Groff | LB | 2017 |
| Ty Fields | DB | 2018 |
| Jordan Leverette | Special Teams | 2018 |
| Sekou Imani | DL | 2019 |
|
No first-team selected in spring of 2021 (Only All-OAC or Honorable Mention) |
||
| Sekou Imani | DL | 2021 (Fall) |
| Iyan Mitchell | DB | 2021 (Fall) |
| Jon Murray, Jr. | RB | 2021 (Fall) |
| Nick Pankow | LB | 2021 (Fall) |
| Patrick Simon | OL | 2021 (Fall) |
| Anthony Kendall | DB | 2022 |
| George Newcomb | OL | 2023 |