| NAME | PLACE | WEIGHT | YEAR |
| Paul Petrella | Champion | 177 lbs | 1978 |
| Paul Petrella | Third | 177 lbs | 1979 |
| Mark Johnson | Fifth | 167 lbs | 1979 |
| Jim Kerr | Seventh | 126 lbs | 1983 |
| Kevin Higgins | Champion | 177 lbs | 1989 |
| Dan Hulten | Eighth | 158 lbs | 1992 |
| Kelly Keenan | Second | 177 lbs | 1994 |
| Doug Knight | Seventh | 134 lbs | 1994 |
| Kevin Atkins | Eighth | 174 lbs | 2000 |
| Jared Selover | Fourth | 125 lbs | 2003 |
| Devin Carman | Eighth | 197 lbs | 2005 |
| Bryan Kmetz | Second | 285 lbs | 2007 |
| Gino Russo | Sixth | 165 lbs | 2007 |
| Gino Russo | Sixth | 165 lbs | 2008 |
| Jesse Gunter | Third | 125 lbs | 2014 |
| Jesse Gunter | Fourth | 125 lbs | 2015 |
| Garrett Chase | Seventh | 174 lbs | 2015 |
| Jesse Gunter | Fifth | 133 lbs | 2016 |
| Anthony Arroyo | Fifth | 165 lbs | 2017 |
| Chris Doyle | Eighth | 125 lbs | 2018 |
| Anthony Arroyo | Third | 165 lbs | 2018 |
| Charlie Nash | Fourth | 133 lbs. | 2019 |
| Zeckery Lehman | Seventh | 197 lbs. | 2019 |
| Stanley Bleich * | First-Team | 149 lbs. | 2020 |
| Dalton Leightner * | First-Team | 157 lbs. | 2020 |
| Zeckery Lehman * | First-Team | 197 lbs. | 2020 |
| Jack Stanley * | Second-Team | 125 lbs. | 2020 |
| Charlie Nash * | Second-Team | 133 lbs. | 2020 |
| Doug Byrne * | Third-Team | 184 lbs. | 2020 |
| Jacob Decatur | Champion | 125 lbs. | 2022 |
| Michael Petrella | Second | 149 lbs. | 2022 |
| Jacob Decatur | Second | 125 lbs. | 2023 |
| Jaden Hinton | Fourth | 133 lbs. | 2023 |
| Michael Petrella | Champion | 149 lbs. | 2023 |
| Doug Byrne | Fifth | 197 lbs. | 2023 |
| Jacob Decatur | Fourth | 125 lbs. | 2024 |
| Jaden Hinton | Second | 133 lbs. | 2024 |
| Michael Petrella | Champion | 149 lbs | 2024 |