| Singles Wins Leaders (Minimum 21 wins) | ||||
| # | Name | Year | Record | PCT. |
| 1. | James Daly | 2005 | 29-2 | .935 |
| 2. | Joe Horvath | 2012 | 28-2 | .933 |
| James Daly | 2008 | 28-3 | .903 | |
| 4. | Kyle Patterson | 2012 | 27-3 | .900 |
| 5. | James Daly | 2007 | 26-2 | .929 |
| Peter Harris | 2013 | 26-3 | .897 | |
| Mike Wagner | 2005 | 26-4 | .867 | |
| Alexander Kearney | 2012 | 26-5 | .839 | |
| Alex Trzeciak | 2012 | 26-6 | .813 | |
| 10. | Bryan Bartunek | 2000 | 24-0 | 1.000 |
| Alexandre Bourdiaux | 2012 | 24-1 | .960 | |
| Joe Horvath | 2010 | 24-1 | .960 | |
| Joe Horvath | 2013 | 24-3 | .889 | |
| Dominic Polifrone | 2015 | 24-3 | .889 | |
| Nathan Katz | 2015 | 24-4 | .857 | |
| Kyle Patterson | 2013 | 24-5 | .826 | |
| 17. | Kevin Peacock | 1995 | 23-0 | 1.000 |
| Carl Doerschler | 1992 | 23-1 | .958 | |
| 19. | James Daly | 2006 | 22-3 | .880 |
| Alex Trzeciak | 2009 | 22-3 | .880 | |
| Alex Trzeciak | 2011 | 22-5 | .815 | |
| Matt Lachman | 2011 | 22-5 | .815 | |
| Doug Ganim | 2013 | 22-6 | .786 | |
| 24. | Chris Johnson | 1997 | 21-0 | 1.000 |
| Sam Burris | 2009 | 21-3 | .875 | |
| Alexander Kearney | 2013 | 21-3 | .875 | |
| Sam Burris | 2011 | 21-5 | .808 | |
| Joe Horvath | 2011 | 21-5 | .808 | |
| Sam Burris | 2008 | 21-6 | .778 | |
| Dominic Polifrone | 2017-2018 | 21-6 | .778 | |
| Alexander Kearney | 2011 | 21-7 | .750 | |
| Doubles Wins Leaders (Minimum 21 wins) | ||||
| # | Name | Year | Record | PCT. |
| 1. | James Daly | 2005 | 26-3 | .897 |
| Joe Horvath | 2012 | 26-8 | .765 | |
| 3. | Adam Slabodnick | 2005 | 25-2 | .926 |
| Matt McGee | 2024 | 25-6 | .806 | |
| Will Horvath | 2024 | 25-6 | .806 | |
| Alex Trzeciak | 2012 | 25-8 | .758 | |
| 7. | Dominic Polifrone | 2015 | 24-7 | .774 |
| James Daly | 2008 | 24-4 | .857 | |
| Taylor Long | 2011 | 24-7 | .774 | |
| Taylor Long | 2012 | 24-9 | .727 | |
| 11. | Tyler Adams | 2008 | 23-5 | .821 |
| Jim Kucera | 2008 | 23-6 | .793 | |
| Alexander Kearney | 2011 | 23-7 | .767 | |
| 14. | Alexander Kearney | 2013 | 22-1 | .957 |
| Joe Horvath | 2010 | 22-2 | .917 | |
| James Daly | 2007 | 22-3 | .880 | |
| Joe Horvath | 2013 | 22-3 | .880 | |
| Peter Harris | 2015 | 22-4 | .846 | |
| Doug Ganim | 2015 | 22-4 | .846 | |
| Tyler Adams | 2008 | 22-4 | .846 | |
| Alexandre Bourdiaux | 2012 | 22-5 | .815 | |
| Doug Ganim | 2014 | 22-5 | .815 | |
| Peter Harris | 2014 | 22-5 | .815 | |
| 24. | Bryan Bartunek | 2000 | 21-2 | .913 |
| Brad Minrovic | 2013 | 21-5 | .808 | |
| Doug Ganim | 2013 | 21-9 | .700 | |
| Brad Minrovic | 2014 | 21-5 | .808 | |
| Kyle Patterson | 2014 | 21-5 | .808 | |
| Peter Harris | 2013 | 21-9 | .700 | |
| Individual Undefeated Season (min. 10 matches played) | ||
| Name | Year | Record |
| Bryan Bartunek | 2000 | 24-0 |
| Chris Johnson | 1997 | 21-0 |
| Dean Morse | 2003 | 19-0 |
| Brandon May | 2004 | 14-0 |
| Ryan McCartney | 2004 | 11-0 |
| Matt Seitz | 2003 | 10-0 |