| Most Games Played/ Started | |||
| Season: | 51/51 | Six players: Vincent Capolupo, Alexis Castillo, Nick Clark, Ryan Guggenheim, Sean Kolenich and Luke Vonderhaar | 2023 |
| Career: | 189/189 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| At-Bats | |||
| Game: | 7 | Andy Palmer vs. Ohio Northern | 1988 |
| 7 | Spencer Badia at Otterbein | 2018 | |
| Season: | 218 | Alex Ludwick | 2022 |
| 217 | Mark Zimmerman | 2014 | |
| Career: | 802 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Hits | |||
| Game: | 7 | Andy Palmer vs. Ohio Northern | 1988 |
| Season: | 95 | Sean Kolenich | 2023 |
| Career: | 290 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Consecutive Hits: | 10 | Andy Palmer | 1990 |
| Hitting Streak: | 25 games | Chase Knodle | 2018 |
| Runs | |||
| Game: | 6 | Dave Rozzo vs. Hiram | 1986 |
| Mike Turchan vs. Lake Erie | 2002 | ||
| Season: | 66 | Brendan Toughey | 2013 |
| Career: | 208 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Runs Batted-In | |||
| Game: | 11 | Dave Rozzo vs. Hiram | 1986 |
| Season: | 70 | Luke Vonderhaar | 2022 |
| Career: | 173 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Singles | |||
| Season: | 67 | Sean Kolenich | 2023 |
| Career: | 187 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Doubles | |||
| Game: | 4 | Trent Kaltenbach vs. Pitt-Greensburg | 2016 |
| 3 | Phil Stringer vs. Mount Vernon Nazerene | 1990 | |
| Brian Johnson vs. John Carroll | 2001 | ||
| Pat Shannon vs. Case Western Reserve | 2003 | ||
| Mike Turchan vs. Walsh | 2003 | ||
| Kevin Brown vs. Case Western Reserve | 2006 | ||
| Cole Nieto vs. Pitt-Bradford | 2015 | ||
| Alex Marcum vs. John Carroll | 2017 | ||
| Season: | 21 | Luke Vonderhaar | 2023 |
| Career: | 62 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Triples | |||
| Game: | 2 | Max Anastasio at John Carroll | 2024 |
| Season: | 6 | Alex Ludwick | 2019 |
| 6 | Cody Kidd | 2009 | |
| 6 | Nolan Neuschaefer | 2011 and 2013 | |
| 6 | Max Anastasio | 2024 | |
| Career: | 19 | Alex Ludwick | 2018-22 |
| Home Runs | |||
| Game: | 3 | Dave Rozzo vs. Muskingum | 1987 |
| Erik Young vs. John Carroll | 1989 | ||
| Dana Gollner vs. Capital | 1990 | ||
| Season: | 19 | Luke Vonderhaar | 2022 |
| Career: | 34 | Pat Shannon | 2000-03 |
| Hit for Cycle | |||
| Chris Matejcik | vs. Mount Union | May 12, 1994 | |
| Steve Conter | vs. Thomas More (Ky.) | March 12, 2001 | |
| Mike Farrell | vs. Hiram | April 14, 2005 | |
| Cole Nieto | vs. Pitt-Bradford (Pa.) | February 26, 2017 | |
| Walks | |||
| Season: | 49 | Joe Velky | 1986 |
| Career: | 95 | Kyle Chontos | 2012-15 |
| Strikeouts | |||
| Season: | 42 | Trent Kaltenbach |
2016 |
| Career: | 107 | Trent Kaltenbach | 2015-18 |
| Lowest Strikeout Percentage (min. 100 at-bats) | |||
| Season | .071 | Hunter Handel (11 times in 154 at-bats) | 2016 |
| Career: | .101 | Hunter Handel (54 times in 533 at-bats) | 2013-16 |
| Stolen Bases | |||
| Game: | 4 | Jim Anderson | 1991 |
| 4 | Dudley Taw | 2018 | |
| Season: | 34 | Chase Knodle | 2018 |
| Career: | 71 | Bill Snyder | 1980-83 |
| Consecutive: | 43 | Bill Snyder | 1980-81 |
| Highest Stolen Base Percentage (Minimum 15 stolen bases) | |||
| Season: | 100% | Bill Snyder (29-for-29) | 1981 |
| 100% | Brendan Toughey (23-for-23) | 2012 | |
| 100% | Zach Ferster (18-for-18) | 2013 | |
| 100% | Mark Zimmerman (17-for-17) | 2016 | |
| Career: | 96.43% | Eric Hyduk (27-for-29) | 1993-94 |
| Highest On-Base Percentage | |||
| Season: | .612 | Dale Herbert | 1971 |
| Career: | .557 | Joe Velky | 1986-87 |
| Slugging Percentage | |||
| Season: | .828 | Pat Shannon | 2002 |
| Career: | .744 | Pat Shannon | 2000-03 |
| Batting Average | |||
| Season: | .527 | Dale Herbert | 1971 |
| Career: | .402 | Joey Dallas | 1989-92 |