| Year | Name | Team | Position |
| 1979 | Tim Loar * | First-Team | not available |
| 1985 | Andy Weyrich * | First-Team | First Base |
| Jim Stefanik * | First-Team | Outfield | |
| 1987 | Bob Rodriguez * | First-Team | Outfield/ Designated Hitter |
| Joe Velky * | First-Team | Catcher/ Designated Hitter | |
| Erik Young * | First-Team | Outfield | |
| Rich Barberic | Second-Team | First Base | |
| John Floriea | Second-Team | Outfield | |
| Dave Rojeck | Second-Team | Second Base | |
| 1989 | Guy Fisher * | First-Team | Second Base |
| Erik Young | First-Team | Outfield | |
| 1991 | Jeff Kuhn | First-Team | Pitcher |
| 1993 | Darin Haines | First-Team | Pitcher |
| 1994 | Darin Haines | Second-Team | Pitcher |
| Greg Andrego | Second-Team | Second Base | |
| 1995 | Jamie Barton | Second-Team | Pitcher |
| Greg Andrego | Second-Team | Second Base | |
| 1996 | Brian Rudloff | First-Team | Pitcher |
| Tyson Swank | Second-Team | Pitcher | |
| Chris Mineard | Second-Team | Outfield | |
| Ken Davenport | Second-Team | Pitcher | |
| Max Newill | Second-Team | Pitcher | |
| 1997 | Max Newill | First-Team | Pitcher |
| Brian Rudloff | First-Team | Pitcher | |
| Tyson Swank | Second-Team | Pitcher | |
| 1998 | Brian Rudloff * | First-Team | Pitcher |
| Max Newill | Second-Team | Pitcher | |
| 1999 | Scott Jackson | Second-Team | Pitcher |
| Tim Obergefell | Second-Team | Outfield | |
| 2001 | Jim Leffler | First-Team | Shortstop |
| Neil Stein | First-Team | Outfield | |
| Pat Shannon | Second-Team | First Base | |
| 2002 | Jim Leffler | First-Team | Shortstop |
| Pat Shannon | Second-Team | First Base | |
| Todd Bratz | Second-Team | Third Base | |
| 2003 | Jim Leffler | First-Team | Shortstop |
| Pat Shannon | Third-Team | First Base | |
| 2004 | Mike Turchan * | First-Team | Third Base |
| Ryan Petraitis | Second-Team | Designated Hitter | |
| 2007 | Cody Kidd | Second-Team | Outfield |
| 2008 | Cody Kidd * | First-Team | Outfield |
| Nate Luken | First-Team | Second Base | |
| 2009 | Cody Kidd * | First-Team | Outfield |
| Brandon Fredericks | Second-team | Pitcher | |
| Mike Brisky | Second-Team | Outfield | |
| 2010 | Justin Novak | First-Team | Pitcher |
| 2012 | Brendan Toughey * | First-Team | Outfield |
| 2013 | Brendan Toughey *# | First-Team | Outfield |
| Brad Gugliotta | First-Team | Third Base | |
| 2014 | Brad Gugliotta * | First-Team | Third Base |
| 2016 | Hunter Handel | First-Team | First Base/ Designated Hitter |
| 2017 | Spencer Badia * | First-Team | Second Base |
| 2018 | Spencer Badia *# | First-Team | Second Base |
| 2019 | Danny Cody * | First-Team | Pitcher |
| 2022 | Luke Vonderhaar * | First-Team | Infielder |
| 2023 | Luke Vonderhaar * | Infielder | |
| Vincent Capolupo | Outfielder | ||
| Ryan Guggenheim | Utility |
* -- denotes CoSIDA Academic All-America selection; # -- denotes CoSIDA Academic All-America of the Year selection.
This page was last updated on June 9, 2023