Jump to induction classes of the: 2010s | 2000s | 1990s | 1980s | 1970s | 1960s
| Class of 2009 | |
| Jamie Baringer '98 | Soccer |
| Wayne J. Bilinovic '90 | Basketball |
| Jody Crawford Griech '95 | Track |
| Dr. Neal Malicky | Honorary |
| Robert L. Mihuta '49 | Track |
| Jodi Reimer '99 | Volleyball, Basketball |
| William J. Snyder '83 | Baseball |
| Gary A. Stelter '79 | Football |
| Jennifer Swinehart Badertscher '99 | Basketball |
| Class of 2008 | |
| Steve Bankson | Basketball Coach, A.D. |
| Michelle Lenhardt Hartley '98 | Cross Country, Track |
| Doug Haubert '90 | Football |
| Joe Mackey '95 | Basketball |
| Mark Massey '90 | Baseball, Football |
| Rochele Meyer Miller '97 | Track |
| Larry Mills '83 | Football, Baseball |
| Julie Work '98 | Basketball |
| Class of 2007 | |
| Cheryl A. Altizer '82 | Athletic Training |
| Kevin Braaten '97 | Basketball |
| Frank "Digger" Dawson '56 | Honorary |
| Jim Eibel '92 | Football, Track |
| Kelly Keenan '94 | Football, Wrestling |
| Bill Linder '94 | Football, Track |
| Jill Smith Sooy '97 | Volleyball, Basketball |
| Class of 2006 | |
| Terry L. Allerton '68 | Basketball |
| Keith A. Boedicker '83 | Football |
| Joe Dallas '93 | Baseball |
| Gay Wellington Geigel '70 | Basketball |
| Kristenne M. Robison '96 | Track |
| Thomas B. Scholato '88 | Football, Track |
| Roy E. Seitz '43 * | Honorary |
| Justine Waugh Tinline '94 | Swimming |
| Class of 2005 | |
| Shawn Conley Bottcher '95 | Cross Country, Track |
| James P. Clardy '93 * | Football |
| Charles W. Geiss '93 | Football, Track |
| Charles E. Krajacic '82 | Football |
| Amy Chadwick Manco '85 | Softball, Basketball |
| Donald Mohr '47 * | |
| Kelly L. Reblin '93 | Track |
| James P. Tressel '75 | Football |
| Jennifer Willis-Davis '93 | Basketball |
| Erik Young '89 | Football, Baseball |
| Class of 2004 | |
| Stacy Ehrenbeit Blair '92 | Volleyball, Swimming |
| Tony Cipollone '93 | Football, Wrestling |
| Joseph De Mando '49 * | |
| Jenniffer Green '94 | Track |
| Harvey Hopson Jr. '69 | Basketball |
| George Key '77 * | Football, Wrestling |
| Tonia Kwiatkowski '94 | Figure Skating |
| Ingrid Wagner '93 | Soccer |
| Donna Wheeler '92 | Softball |
| Class of 2003 | |
| Sandra Tom Cibulskas '93 | Swimming |
| Wynn Hawkins '58 | Basketball |
| Julie A. Jones '92 | Softball |
| John H. Koz '93 | Football |
| Janet Knoll Lano '84 | Volleyball, Basketball, Softball, Track |
| James L. Magazine '86 | Baseball |
| Derek E. McKinley '82 | Track |
| Larry K. Van Dusen | Football Coach |
| Class of 2002 | |
| Roger Andrachik '80 | Football |
| Jennifer Fish Baker '71 | Olympic Speed Skater |
| Stephanie Fleming Dolejs '90 | Basketball |
| Paul Ernst '78 | Football |
| Annette Heidersbach '87 | Cross Country, Track |
| Richard Lowry '57 | Football, Basketball |
| Brian Moore '85 | |
| Robert Packard '65 * | Football, Coach |
| Kim Smith Gallagher '92 | Track |
| Dr. Carol Thompson | Coach |
| Class of 2001 | |
| Doris Zabriskie Billings '60 | |
| Lance W. Currens '84 | Football, Track |
| Peggy S. Fortune Yetman '91 | Cross Country, Track, Swimming |
| Barbara A. Hunter '90 | Cross Country, Track |
| Kim Stuart Kaminski '90 | Track, Basketball |
| Dean S. Martin '73 | Basketball |
| John "Jack" Mental, Jr. '69 | Football |
| James M. Stefanik '85 | Baseball |
| Eloise Schaefer Tressel '72 * | Athletic Archivist |
| Class of 2000 | |
| Karen Palmer Cochran '68 | |
| David R. Demmerle * | Coach |
| Peggy Grandinetti '87 | Volleyball, Softball |
| Kevin S. Higgins '89 | Wrestling |
| Sharon B. Hosko '84 | Volleyball, Softball |
| Timothy J. Skoczen '80 | Football |
| Gregory E. Thomas '70 * | Football |
| Lisa Winans '90 | Cross Country, Track |
* - denotes deceased member