| Year | Captains |
| 1920 | Wig Pfeifer |
| 1921 | Stubby Warner |
| 1922 | Oran Zaebst |
| 1923 | Granville Robinson |
| 1924 | Harold Bender |
| 1925 | Paul Lisse |
| 1926 | Robert Homan |
| 1927 | Dennis Schill |
| 1928 | Ken Lower |
| 1929 | Boyd Robinson |
| 1930 | Kenneth Weber |
| 1931 | Kingsley Eckert |
| 1932 | Charles Kebl |
| 1933 | Ray Gedeon |
| 1934 | Pete Barno |
| 1935 | Gordon Splete |
| 1936 | Ken Noble |
| 1937 | Bill Davidson |
| 1938 | Floyd Storey |
| 1939 | Ray Shertzer |
| 1940 | Woddie Scoutten |
| 1941 | Ray Swoger |
| 1942 | Robert Eckhardt |
| 1943 | Vern Fesco |
| 1944 | Lee Tressel |
| 1945 | Bob Wallace |
| 1946 | Don Mohr |
| 1947 | Keith Piper |
| 1948 | Joe Demando |
| 1949 | Tom Phillips |
| 1950 | Bob Ferry |
| 1951 | Frank Bursa |
| 1952 | Lou Ralston |
| 1953 | Dick Miller |
| 1954 | Jim Tyree |
| 1955 | Don Chadwick |
| 1956 | Don Kelley and Dick Lowry |
| 1957 | John Moore |
| 1958 | Bob Barrett |
| 1959 | Chuck Brady and Joe Los |
| 1960 | Dave Adams and Dick Barbeck |
| 1961 | Obie Bender and Bill Lacey |
| 1962 | Tom French, Tom Goosby and Art Van Rensselaer |
| 1963 | Joe Carter and Larry Shinn |
| 1964 | Owen Davidson and Ernie Prince |
| 1965 | Dave Dourm and Steve Hays |
| 1966 | Steve Boulton, John Terakedis and Joe Yore |
| 1967 | Tom McGill |
| 1968 | Vern Sharbaugh and Jim Westbrook |
| 1969 | Larry Hoon, Ron Stephonic and Greg Thomas |
| 1970 | Tom Maher and Larry Sklenka |
| 1971 | Dave Coad |
| 1972 | Chet Cudzillo, Ed Casey, John Yezerski and Jim King |
| 1973 | George Golden and Joe DeChant |
| 1974 | Mark Summers and Jim Tressel |
| 1975 | Gary Nash and Sam Crumpton |
| 1976 | Andy Laibe and Bob Spicer |
| 1977 | Greg Rufus and Paul Ernst |
| 1978 | Joe Surniak, Roger Andrachik and Gary Stelter |
| 1979 | Bob Wujek, Ray Hradek and Mike Hoon |
| 1980 | Brett Albright, Dan Delfino and Dave Ward |
| 1981 | Mike Graven, Corey Hamilton and Dave Nofsinger |
| 1982 | Mark Rodriguez |
| 1983 | Lance Currens and Dave Rodriguez |
| 1984 | Chuck Carmichael and John Price |
| 1985 | Kert Boedicker and Mark Schwertner |
| 1986 | Jeff Welcsh and John Hribar |
| 1987 | Dirk Riemenschneider and Jerry Sponseller |
| 1988 | Kirk Davisd |
| 1989 | Dan Andrews, Matt Kubinski and Phil Medvetz |
| 1990 | Mike Rodak, Scott Shafer and Colin Johnson |
| 1991 | Marcus Macalla and Jeff Stetler |
| 1992 | Chuck Geiss, Tom Garfield, Jim Clardy and Dennis Neate |
| 1993 | John Koz and Tim Jansen |
| 1994 | Phil Evans, Tom Kne and Phil Sahley |
| 1995 | Tom Farkas, Dean Lasley, Tony Oden and Mike Zografos |
| 1996 | Brandon Felger, Fred Saylor and Matt Vojtech |
| 1997 | Lutul Farrow, Fred Saylor and Josh Cantwell |
| 1998 | Geoff Helmlinger, JoJo Saccoccia, J.F. Babitsky and Brian Cook |
| 1999 | Matt Andreas, Brian Dever, Greg Hanchuk and Marwan Maalouf |
| 2000 | Todd Bacik and Joe Dobies |
| 2001 | Dan Aranyosi and Julius Holinek |
| 2002 | Gerald Hazzard and Matt Kish |
| 2003 | Tom DeLuca and Dan Larlham |
| 2004 | Josh Jameyson and Mike Scarcella |
| 2005 | Joe George and Justin Princehorn |
| 2006 | Dave Brown, Brandon Hedges, Adam Laurell and Rob Lewis |
| 2007 | Darren Cereshko, Luke Chronister, Matt Leber and Mickey Mental |
| 2008 | John DiMattio, Joe Kowalski, Matt Lepley and Karl Schreiber |
| 2009 | Paul Burger, Ryan Clokey, Anthony Gardner and Brett Scarl |
| 2010 | Keith Darbutt, Ryan Dugan, Ryan Kish and Kevin Phipps and |
| 2011 | Jimmy Basar, Ryan Dugan, Tim Miker and Ryan O'Rourke |
| 2012 | Brian Ellis, Nick Milano, Ryan O'Rourke and Max Wagner |
| 2013 | Zach Barley, Jason Cook, Josiah Holt, Mike Stacchiotti and Zac Wojciechowski |
| 2014 | Addison Carbone, Sean Hemlick, Dan O’Brien and Luke Riemenschneider |
| 2015 | Tyler Burdorff, Josh Lane, Tyler Moeglin and Isaac Reed III |
| 2016 | Sam Groff, Brock Hull, Alex Kurtz and Andy Schultz |
| 2017 | Sam Groff, Sean Nischwitz, Andy Schultz, Andrew Sierawski and Trypp Washington |
| 2018 | Ty Fields, Andrew Groves, Jake Hudson, Josh Liberati and Rob Wolfington |
| 2019 | Noah Jackson, Jordyn Johnson, Josh Liberati, A.J. Miller and Patrick Simon |
| 2020 | Assigned by Coaching Staff for Each Game |
| 2021 (Spring) | Assigned by Coaching Staff for Each Game |
| 2021 (Fall) | Assigned by Coaching Staff for Each Game |
| 2022 | Assigned by Coaching Staff for Each Game |
| 2023 | Assigned by Coaching Staff for Each Game |