| Team |
Series Began |
Series Record |
Winning Streak |
Last Meeting/ Score / Location of Game |
| Alfred State (N.Y.) |
2014 |
2-0 |
BW - 2 |
2015, BW won, 22-1 , in Alfred, N.Y. |
| Alfred University (N.Y.) |
2016 |
0-1 |
AU - 1 |
2016, AU won, 13-11, in Alfred, N.Y. |
| Alma (Mich.) |
2016 |
3-0 |
BW - 3 |
2018, BW won, 12-5, in Berea |
| Bethany (W. Va.) |
2014 |
2-0 |
BW - 2 |
2014, BW won, 17-2, in Berea |
| Brockport State (N.Y.) |
2019 |
0-1 |
BR - 1 |
2019, Brockport won, 12-9, in Berea |
| Calvin (Mich.) |
2013 |
2-0 |
BW - 2 |
2014, BW won, 17-9, in Grand Rapids, Mich. |
| CAPITAL * |
2014 |
4-3 |
CU - 1 |
2019, CU won, 16-12, in Berea |
| Cleveland State |
2017 |
0-1 |
CSU - 1 |
2017, CSU won, 9-2, in Cleveland |
| Franciscan |
2013 |
3-0 |
BW - 3 |
2015, BW won, 31-1, in Berea |
| SUNY Geneseao (N.Y.) |
2019 |
1-0 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 13-10, in Geneseo, N.Y. |
| Grove City (Pa.) |
2019 |
1-0 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 12-11, in Berea |
| Hanover (Ind.) |
2014 |
2-1 |
BW - 2 |
2016, BW won, 17-4 , in Hanover, Ind. |
| HEIDELBERG * |
2017 |
3-0 |
BW - 3 |
2019, BW won, 25-4, in Berea |
| Hope (Mich.) |
2013 |
0-1 |
HC - 1 |
2014, HC won, 14-9 , in Pontiac, Mich. |
| Houghton (N.Y.) |
2013 |
2-0 |
BW - 2 |
2014, BW won, 19-2, in Houghton, N.Y. |
| JOHN CARROLL * |
2016 |
3-5 |
JCU - 1 |
2019, JCU won, 14-12 (OAC Trny.), in Berea |
| Kenyon |
2019 |
1-0 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 17-16, in Gambier |
| LaRoche (Pa.) |
2016 |
2-0 |
BW - 2 |
2016, BW won, 18-4, in McCandless Twp., Pa. |
| MARIETTA * |
2019 |
1-0 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 30-5, in Berea |
| MOUNT UNION * |
2013 |
5-1 |
BW - 5 |
2019, BW won, 17-6, in Alliance |
| MUSKINGUM * |
2015 |
5-0 |
BW - 5 |
2019, BW won, 28-7, in New Concord |
| Oberlin |
2015 |
3-0 |
BW - 3 |
2017, BW won, 18-5, in Oberlin |
| OHIO NORTHERN * |
2016 |
4-1 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 16-14, in Berea |
| Ohio Valley |
2013 |
0-1 |
OVU - 1 |
2013, OVU won, 9-8, in Vienna, W.Va. |
| Olivet (Mich.) |
2018 |
2-1 |
BW - 2 |
2018, BW won, 28-5 , in Olivet, Mich. |
| OTTERBEIN * |
2014 |
3-6 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 17-15, in Westerville |
| Saint Vincent (Pa.) |
2014 |
5-1 |
BW - 5 |
2019, BW won, 21-6 , in Berea |
| Southern Virginia |
2018 |
0-1 |
SVU - 1 |
SVU won, 18-13, at Frostburg State (Md.) |
| Thiel (Pa.) |
2013 |
0-2 |
TC - 2 |
2014, TC won, 14-11, in Greenville, Pa. |
| Transylvania (Ky.) |
2017 |
2-1 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 18-10, in Berea |
| Trine (Ind.) |
2013 |
2-1 |
BW - 2 |
2016, BW won, 7-4, in Berea |
| Washington & Jefferson (Pa.) |
2015 |
4-0 |
BW-4 |
2018, BW won, 26-1, in Washington, Pa. |
| WILMINGTON * |
2013 |
7-0 |
BW - 7 |
2019, BW won, 34-4, in Wilmington |
| Wooster |
2019 |
1-0 |
BW - 1 |
2019, BW won, 15-11, in Wooster |